Saturday, May 19, 2012

Baked Sunday Mornings: Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie

When I saw that Baked Sunday Mornings was making this pie I immediately thought of how I love peanut butter and banana sandwiches and knew that I did not want to pass this one up.  I didn't really eat pb and banana sandwiches as a kid, I think my love for them started when I was a little older.  I remember making peanut butter, cream cheese, honey and banana sandwiches for my son when he was little....not sure if I was making them for him or me!!  So this really is a sort of Elvis Presley Pie...right?  LOL!  Anyway!  I know one thing is for certain, this pie will get you "All Shook up!"  Did Elvis put bacon on his grilled pb and banana sandwich???  Hmmm....some say he did and some say he didn't.  If he did you could get out that candied bacon, chop it up and sprinkle it on top of pie and have a real Elvispalooza!

This pie was fairly easy to put together.  The vanilla pudding was pretty simple and it turned out sooooo good!  The vanilla wafer crust was made in the food processor with butter and a little sugar.  Did you know that vanilla wafers taste like marshmallows??  They do!  Never realized that until I saw somebody mention it in another blog.  The peanut butter layer was made with cream cheese, confectioners sugar, vanilla, peanut butter and whipped cream!!!  Whoa! 

Is your mouth watering yet all you peanut butter and banana fans????  
It should be!
The Baked Boys Did it Again!  
This pie is a winner!  
Make it....NOW!

Please check out what the other Baked Sunday Mornings bakers 
did and get the recipe here 
Thank you...thank you very much...*lip snarl and hip wiggle* 



  1. Yes, my mouth is watering, Chelly! Your pie is just gorgeous! One of my brothers loved pb and banana sandwiches, but I didn't eat them that often. I did love this pie though and loved even the little bit of chocolate that I drizzled on top. Yours looks just so delicious and inviting. Great job!

  2. What a beautiful from a really high end restaurant...very professional. Your presentation is perfect. And I enjoyed your write-up...makes me want another piece of this pie.

  3. holy beautiful pie! seriously gorgeous!

  4. I love your topping. So pretty!

  5. I love how you took a picture with your pie and the one in the book. I think yours looks beautiful (and I love your Elvis graphic).

  6. Gorgeous! I love the design on the top of your pie! I also love the final pic - cute!

  7. love the swirl design on top of your pie! i tried to do that but it didn't look great, so i just spread it back and forth.

  8. Wow, Chelly! You really knocked this one out of the park! It's just gorgeous! I skipped this week, but will definitely copy your crushed chocolate covered peanuts when I do make it!

  9. Great post! Your pie is so incredibly professional looking! What perfection!

  10. This is gorgeous! I'm baking from this book today too! :) Your pie is even more beautiful than the pic in the book!


Thanks for taking the time to visit my blog. I blog for your comments...please let me know what you think!!